When you own the team you can do whatever you want.
The problem for some owners is that what they want to do is not good for their team. I know what you’re thinking before I write this next line, but I’m not referring to Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones, not yet anyway, but rather the owner of the team that his squad is meeting this week in Indianapolis, the Colts.
The ownership of the Colts franchise has been in the Irsay family since the current owner’s grandfather, Robert Irsay, purchased the Los Angeles Rams from the estate of the late owner, Dan Reeves, for $19 million. Irsay wanted a National Football League team closer to his primary business located in Chicago, so soon after acquiring the Rams he made an ownership swap with Baltimore Colts owner Caroll Rosenbloom.
The Rams thrived under Rosenbloom's ownership while the Colts floundered. One of the NFL franchises with the richest history in the game, read that as Johnny Unitas, was relegated to second tier status. In the dead of night, Robert Irsay moved the Colts from Baltimore and relocated the team to Indianapolis in 1984.
The Colts redemption began in 1998 with the drafting of future Hall of Fame Quarterback Peyton Manning. By this time, the franchise was being run by Robert Irsay’s son, Jim Irsay, who had a reputation as good as his dad’s was bad. The Colts enjoyed mostly successful years with the younger Irsay running the franchise and captured a Super Bowl to complete the 2006 season, which was ten years after Robert had died.
On May 21, 2025, Jim Irsay died and following his death the ownership of the Colts transferred to his three daughters, Carlie, Casey and Kalen. Carlie became the team’s principal owner and CEO.
And a new set of problems arose for this franchise.
It appears that successful ownership skips a generation in the Irsay family. Robert was one of the most disliked characters in the NFL, his son was both liked and respected, and the early returns during the management of Carlie Irsay-Gordon has not been good.
She takes a position on the sidelines during games with headphones tuned into the coaches and with a clipboard she is constantly referring to. I don’t think any owner would be served by stalking his or her staff and players on game day … and it appears just a little worse, no sexist bias intended, with a woman roaming among her players and staff during games.
The Colts are in full dismantle mode, in October they fired general manager Chris Ballard and a week later traded two of their best players. They got draft choices in deals that sent All-Pro offensive guard Quenton Nelson to the Seattle Seahawks and Pro Bowl defensive tackle DeForest Buckner to the San Francisco 49ers.
Do I want to bet on the Colts with this mismanagement at the top?
No.
But this week they host the Dallas Cowboys with an owner who has interfered with team progress since he separated ways with head coach Jimmy Johnson in 1993. Jones had a good thing going with Johnson. He hired his onetime college football teammate to coach his newly acquired team. It was a great hire; Jimmy came in knowing what he wanted to do and starting from a 1-15 season in 1989 he led a Super Bowl win just four seasons later.
In 1993, Johnson led the Cowboys to a second straight title but for Jones’ taste his head coach was getting too much credit and Jones wanted some accolades of his own. So, he fired Johnson and the team Jimmy built was able to earn one more Vince Lombardi Trophy in the 1995 season while Barry Switzer benefited from the team Johnson had built.
The Cowboys haven’t been back to the Super since.
So, we have these two owners who do neither of their teams any good at winning games, against each other Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium. What is the better play? Taking the Cowboys as a road favorite or backing the hobbled Colts at home getting points?
Brings me back to a point that serves up winners consistently, that is, good picks don’t always win, but bad picks always lose. The Cowboys as a road favorite is a bad pick, which leaves the Colts the selection by default.
Qoxhi Picks: Indianapolis Colts (+5) over Dallas Cowboys