The New York Giants are alone atop the NFC East Division with three wins in four games. The Dallas Cowboys, who came into the week one game back, have already dropped another game behind the division leading Giants with their home loss last night to the previously winless Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
On Sunday, the Philadelphia Eagles, who have lost two straight games, are underdogs against the Jacksonville Jaguars in London. They started this week a full game behind the Giants and are likely to lose their third straight game.
How good is this for New York’s first-year Head Coach John Harbaugh?
And how unexpected is it in light of the Giants losing their starting quarterback for the season when Jaxson Dart went down with a season ending knee injury during second week action on the road against the Los Angeles Rams? Without Dart, the Giants went on to lose a lopsided decision, 28-6, to Matthew Stafford and company, but have now won the past two weeks.
The Giants had such high hopes for their second-year signal caller, and he looked great in the Giants season opening win over the Cowboys. The coaching of Harbaugh and his staff along with a year under his belt seemed to turn Dart from a rookie with promise to a second-year pro ready to lead his team into the postseason.
Those dreams were doused by his season ending injury.
Now what for the Giants?
They have had veteran quarterback Jameis Winston on their roster just for a situation like this. Well, not really like this, Winston was there in case Dart missed some playing time and he was needed in a relief role. The fact that Dart is out for the year and Winston is now the Giants starter was not part of the plan New York had for the 2026 season.
The fact that Winston won his first start while leading the Giants to a low-scoring 12-7 triumph over the Tennessee Titans at MetLife Stadium did not dramatically move the needle on the Giants perceived need for help at quarterback. Their next best solution was to trade with the Minnesota Vikings to bring in another one-time first round draft choice, J.J. McCarthy, to perhaps develop into what Minnesota had banked on since making him the tenth overall selection in the 2024 NFL draft.
In his last collegiate season at Michigan, McCarthy led the Wolverines to a perfect 15-0 record and the national championship. Since becoming a pro, McCarthy has shown flashes of the quarterback Minnesota had hoped he would be, but had spent more time on the injured list than on the field during his two plus years on Kevin O’Connell's squad.
The Vikings also made a full commitment to McCarthy both financially and while opening all the chances available for him to step into becoming a franchise NFL quarterback. While spending his rookie season on the injured list, Minnesota turned to recently acquired veteran Sam Darnold to lead their team. The one-time top pick of the New York Jets responded by leading the Vikings to the second most regular season wins in their franchise history, 14.
Despite his great play, and because of it, Darnold had priced himself out of the backup price range and Minnesota was stuck between having made a full commitment to McCarthy and not being able to afford both him and Darnold. The Vikings let Darnold move on to the Seattle Seahawks, where he became only the second quarterback in history to lead his team to consecutive 14 wins seasons and ended his first campaign in Seattle with a Super Bowl trophy.
Back in Minnesota, the Vikings decision to keep McCarthy landed with a thud.
The product out of Michigan started ten games for the Vikings last season with a 6-4 record … but was injured for seven weeks in which Carson Wentz and rookie Max Brosmer filled in and compiled a 3 and 4 combined record.
The Vikings have moved on while acquiring another one-time first round draft choice, Kyler Murray. Minnesota announced that the quarterback role would be decided on the field during the preseason; but the decision was clearly already etched in stone. It was Murray’s job to lose. So far, while hurt in the Vikings opening win over the Green Bay Packers and missing second week action, Murray has guided the Vikings to a pair of wins over the past two weeks and Minnesota is one of three NFL teams that come into this week with a 4-0 mark.
The organization, with recent success and hopes Murray would be their long-term answer, were anxious to rid themselves of the McCarthy distraction. At the same time, the Giants were looking not only for a possible backup to Winston, but more importantly a potential starter for this season. The Vikings looking to unload McCarthy and the Giants in need of a quarterback led Minnesota to hand off their young quarterback to Harbaugh and company for a fifth-round draft choice.
Now the Giants, alone atop the NFC East with their 3-1 record and buoyed by Dallas’ loss last night, travel to our nation’s capital to meet a Commanders squad who will get back the services of Jayden Daniels, who injured his elbow in their second week loss to the Cowboys. The Commanders lost both of Daniels' starts this season and split the games when quarterbacks Marcus Mariota and rookie Athan Kaliakmanis led their charges.
The Commanders, behind Mariota, beat the defending Super Bowl Champions in third week action and were downed last week in London by the Indianapolis Colts. Mariota was injured early in that international game and replaced by rookie seventh round draft choice Kaliakmanis.
This week, the Commanders get Daniels back, are at home, and need a win to cut their deficit in the standings behind the Giants to one game. That’s right, a Giants win strengthens their lead in their division race and drops the Commanders three games behind New York and in last place.
In other words, and you’ve heard this from me before, the Giants want this one and the Commanders need it.
Need over want every time.
Qoxhi Picks: Washington Commanders (-4) over New York Giants